PhD candidates will be exempted from clearing NET for Assistant Professor: UGC New Regulations invite feedbacks

New Delhi, 09 February 2018: In a landmark development that will have greater impact on the Direct Recruitment process adopted by the Universities, Colleges, and other higher educational institutes,  the University Grants Commission (UGC) has released today Draft of new Regulations on Minimum Qualifications for Appointment of Teachers and Other Academic Staff in these institutes.

In the draft of these new regulations, the UGC has suggested many changes and revises norms in minimum eligibility rules for the engagement of assistant professors in various universities and institutes.

AD



PhD degree holders will be exempted from the requirement of the minimum eligibility condition of NET/SLET/SET for recruitment and appointment of Assistant Professor or equivalent positions in Universities / Colleges / Institutions.

The Draft clarified that the National Eligibility Test (NET), or an accredited test (State Level Eligibility Test SET/SLET) shall remain the minimum eligibility for appointment of Assistant Professor and equivalent positions wherever provided in these regulations. Further, SLET/SET shall be valid as the minimum eligibility for direct recruitment to Universities/Colleges/Institutions under the control of the respective state only.



PhD Degree holders will get advantage: In another new change, the Draft Report of the new Regulation said the PhD Degree shall be a mandatory qualification for promotion to the post of Assistant Professor (Selection Grade/Academic Level 12) in Universities.  The draft mentioned that the PhD Degree shall be a mandatory qualification for direct recruitment to the post of Assistant Professor in Universities with effect from 01 July 2021. For promotion to the post of Assistant Professor (Selection Grade/Academic Level 12) in Colleges, the PhD shall be a mandatory qualification if the date of eligibility falls on or after 01 July 2021.

The PhD Degree shall be a mandatory qualification for the appointment and promotion to the post of Professors. The PhD Degree shall be a mandatory qualification for appointment and promotion to the post of Associate Professors.

Time spent during PhD course will not be counted as Teaching Experience: The period of time taken by candidates to acquire MPhil and/or PhD Degree shall not be considered as teaching/ research experience to be claimed for appointment to the teaching positions. Further the period of active service spent on pursuing Research Degree simultaneously with teaching assignment without taking any kind of leave shall be counted as teaching experience for the purpose of direct recruitment/ promotion. The period of leave taken for pursuing Research Degree i.e. for acquiring PhD degree shall not be counted as teaching experience for the purpose of direct recruitment/ promotion.

The UGC has invited Feedback/Comments/Suggestions from the Stakeholders/ General public on Draft UGC Regulations for (Minimum Qualifications for Appointment of Teachers and Other Academic Staff in Universities & Colleges and measures for the Maintenance of Standards in Higher Education) 2018.

Interested candidates can send their feedback/comments/suggestions on the above draft documents to UGC by email on : ugcregulations2017@gmail.com on or before 28 February 2018 by midnight.

The Draft categorized the teaching staff in broadly five types: Assistant Professors, Associate Professors, Professors, Senior Professors, and Principals.

The minimum qualifications required for the post of Assistant Professors, Associate Professors, Professors, Senior Professors, Principals, Assistant Librarians, Deputy Librarians, Librarians, Assistant Directors of Physical Education and Sports, Deputy Directors of Physical Education and Sports and Directors of Physical Education and Sports, shall be as prescribed by the UGC in these Regulations.

Related Posts

  1. NET exam is outdated, most of the question are based on what, where, when, which, who a collection of memory based or general knowledge type which neither help in teaching or in research. If the UGC dont believe in its University capability of awarding Phd to deserving know based students; for good close the UGC itself. NET exam is in by large a huge way of wasting money which can be used in value added research. And support if a just Master level past out students with NET anf JRF able to teach phd students.

    1. exactly my friend, our country is the only one which conducts such types of exams to judge research aptitude as well as teaching aptitude, this types of examination system is outdated in most of the countries… in my opinion, these exams should be the eligibility for scholarship only

  2. It will be a landmark decision and can bring a grate relief for the candidates waiting for a better opportunity in the field teaching

  3. It’s not a justice with NET /SET qualified candidates. If IAS exam is compulsory for Collector then NET/SET is also compulsory for Asst. Professor, Aap log Quality education ka mazak Qu bana rahe hai. what’s your problem, thousands of NET /SET qualified candidates are available

    1. Different universities have different level of education quality for providing PhD degree, Net is only parameter to judge the quality of students in a single exam without any biasness in a whole country. Quality of exam may be modified.

      1. I think there is no equality between NET and Ph.d. In Ph.d we work on single theory but to clear NET we have to study whole literature and is more laborious. Candidate with both should be preferred for selection in universities. It is very sad that marks for Ph.d are more than NET. SET.

    1. exactly. net is just mcqt which requires
      memorisation of subject but phd is 3 -5 years long research programme.
      how people can treat phd as inferior than net ? some friends here , without knowing reality of research says that phd degree can be obtained through money and political influence. how they dare to think like that? i want to say that obtaining phd degree is not a joke. please dont compare it with net.

    2. all the state universities in India having minimum eligibility for lecturership position is NET, not PhD, and we all know the quality of research and education in those universities. while NITs, IITs, IISERs, and other centralised institution do not have such criteria, and again we all know the quality of education there.

  4. It’s not commendable sir….we have net, we still jobless. If It is advantage for phd holders not having net is not fair to the net cleared candidate.then what is the difference between criteria qualified or none qualified. Please sir don’t implement this idea, else the number of jobless people will be increased more.thanks

    1. Unemployed PhD holders are also job seekers. Why not thinking about him. Why are you thinking only for net slet only? Let’s be a broad minded and demand job for all.

  5. I think NET-qualification should be mandatory. It actually judge the candidate’s academic potential. Only, Candidates with good subject-conception can qualify the NET.

    1. I agree with you. If a survey is taken net qualified and pH.d qualified in the last 5 year, net qualified will be less only. to qualify net we have to compete with overall in India not as doing pH.d in a college under a university.

  6. Intelligence or knowledge has nothing much to do with getting a PhD in most cases. Often social and political skills become more even more important in getting this degree. Any Dick and Harry can have it but that is not true for UGC/CSIR NET. It is more knowledge based.

      1. In 2006 m.phil can be completed in 1yr even in distance mode. For pH.d before 2010 we need guide help and our hardwork. But now a days money , publications with the stipulated year pH.d can be awarded. But for net you and you only have to sit and prepare all the subjects. The questions are not direct as you think.

  7. The quality of education and research would come down. There are people who can manage to get phd. Off course there are instances where people manage to get net by piloting in the exam.

    1. Net/slet should not be compulsory criteria for appointment of assistant professor. PhD should be the criteria…either PhD or net for the post of assistant professor job.. net should not be conpulsory criteria.

  8. It is a very good proposal as PhD should be the eligibility criteria to teach students at both BA and MA levels. People who have PhD degrees hence can be exempted from clearing NET as 5-6 years of research experience and acumen prepares you much more and much better to be a good and effective teacher as compared to clearing a competitive exam which can be mugged up in a month. Hence please kindly revise the rules and make PhD mandatory so that students who have an academic bent of mind and are serious about pursuing research gets to teach posterity.

  9. UGC changes qualification for the appointment of assistant professor from time to time for better teaching standards.. But several state governments are using the changes for their advantages…. Many youth with M. Phil are struggling

  10. NET shall be compusory for appointment and ph.D shall not be exempted from acquiring NET in order to maintain standared and balance of higher education

  11. I am not agreed with this changes and new norms for qualified and eligible for post of assistant professor.
    NET, SLET & SET SHOULD BE REMAINED MANDATORY FOR PH.D HOLDERS AS WELL AS FOR PG HOLDER.
    Dear UGC,
    Ph.D degree is just an academic degree any body can pursue their Ph.D degree through academic and holded Ph.D degree may be teach better but they do not have an ethic to become a Assistant professor inspite that, If Ph.D holders donot clear their NET, SLET & SET tests then how they become and eligible for assistant professor so NET SLET AND SET should be mandatory for everyone.
    Personal Views,
    I personally feel that, NET, SLET AND SET are such a Test which makes an interest to the students to become a assistant professor and these tests are create to strong ethic towards professionalism.

    ”Keep present Norms and regulations remain.”

  12. Make NET compulsory, PhD may not be. In My personal view, teaching is a skill, Skill oriented certification is better than PhD.

  13. Wrong move. Most of the Ph. Ds concentrate narrow down their study to one tiny subfield. They lack broad knowledge in all the subjects that they are expected to teach. This affects their teaching and ultimately students are the sufferers. Both Ph.D and NET is to be made mandatory at leastin CFIs.

  14. I sujest that PhD degree is minimum qualification in research area. In teaching or for assistant professor selection process modified like upsc exam or based on modified selection processes who will teach good or not. The need of teaching facility or process at primary teaching level this is the basic need in Indian education system at present time. selection process is very wrong.

    1. Teaching is an art. Nobody can acquire this art after passing any competitive exam like NET or SET. I have personally observed this fact. A person even after passing this exam can not be a best teacher. There are so many private institutions in which we find great teachers without NET or SET. Therefore a decision will be beneficial for those who could not enter into the academics only because of want of NET/SET. Govt. was constraint to appoint a person as a teacher only because he is possessing NET/SET exam. even accepting the fact that he does not possess teaching potential or capability. It was till date a monopoly of the possessors of this degree at the cost of society. Now the scenario will definitely improve 100%. My words.

  15. Doing research for more than 3 three years cannot be compared to the preparation for an exam like NET/SET. The PhD gives more authenticity to teach than passing an exam.

  16. i totally agree to the initiative ugc is taking…. ph.d holders should be exempted from net/slet and should be directly applicable for the post of assistance professor

  17. 1. No, net and phd holder should not be equally eligible for the post of assistant professor. .ek pdh holder ka resarch work history jaise visha vishya k ek topic pr hota h isse us insan ki pure itihas vishya pr uski knowledge ka uski samajh ka pta nhi chalta ..ho sakta h vo apne resarch k topic me acha ho pr baki history ka use gyan na jabki use student ko pdhna sara subject h na ki sirf uska resarch topic…net ki preparation k bad pure subject ki samjh ache se ban jati h kiu ki net ka paper hi is level ka hota h vo aapke subject ko aap ko aap k dimag me pura dale bina clear ho hi nhi sakta ..ek topic pr resarch kr k aap net clear kiye huye insan k equal kaise ho sakte ho … mere hisab se ye badlav krna bari galati hogi .
    2. Or pdh k during jo scholar apni resarch work k sath pdha rha h use bhi experience me count krna chaiye .

  18. NET/SET MUST BE COMPULSORY. Only on basis of PH.D candidates should not be made eligible for Assistant professor…

  19. Please exempt NET..
    Instead focus on knowledge with teaching skills…
    Mere NET will not tell that you are capable of teaching in a right way..
    Such knowledge is something which can never be used ..

    1. Realy it is a very good decision.It will increase the research potentiality and encourage young students in the research field,hence increase the humen resoures in the in country.A good ph d scholar ,not only expert in teaching but also expeart in many areas of the academic field.

  20. Ph.D is only Research Area. Ph. D. Nothing including teaching skills.Once you register your self for Ph.D. you get Ph.D. anyhow But NET / SET is very tuff and good exam like UPSC and MPSC.
    So keep NET / SET for assistance professor.

  21. NET should be only criteria for recruitment plus category like SC ST OBC should be removed when results are considered because a general category guy scores more than SC ST OBC still not qualified but SC ST OBC are scoring less and are still qualified.

    SC ST OBC guy scoring less marks and still qualifying on what basis that person is better then a general category guy who scored more and still not qualified.

    And for PhD it’s easy toh get PhD from any local college but to clear NET is tough so such people who become professor ruin education system which is almost ruined in some city’s.

  22. Yes, it is a revolutionary step.
    PhD should be mandatory for teaching. Unless a teacher is a good Researcher, the wisdom can not be reachable.

  23. Phenomenal decision..such steps should hv been taken long back as many desired candidates dont get placement due to this criteria..and clearing net in few subjects such as lifescience is very tough.

  24. The candidates who have acquired their M.Phil Degree from any state or central university before July 2009 should also be eligible for Assistant Professor /Assistant Librarian in Colleges or University

  25. Right decision pls take one more step for Assistant professor selection procedure candidate eligibility 55% ka compulsary hona bhi jaruri nhi hai bcz percentage is nt perfact parameter of candidate teaching skils may be candidate teaching skils &effective teaching approch is more important in place of 55% tn will get more option .

    1. true
      just one bad marksheet should not decide your future. if someone has not been very consistent in his academic records but has earned a PhD and qualified UGC-NET as well as SET, He/She must be allowed to compete for the recruitment.
      you should write your feedback to UGC on ugcregulations2017@gmail.com on or before 28 February 2018 by midnight.

  26. Right decision take one more step selection procedure in Assistant professor 55% eligibility is not compulsary bcz i think in place of percentage effective teaching skils is more important for improvement of teaching system bcz lot of perfect people are not eligible to teaching due to percentage

  27. Counting teaching experience for active service during Ph.d years is most welcome.taking full time classes and pursuing ph.d side by side is tremendous workload. No different from double shift. So they rightly deserve teaching experience. Denying them the same would be injustice.

  28. NET should be mendetory for assistant professor post. A lot of students who has completed his /her PH.D till not qualified net. Most of them purchase their PH.D degree from universities if they will join in college the future of students will be dark. PH.d,should be mendetory only in promotion .NET should be compulsory for all candidates .

  29. The candidates who have acquired their m.Phil. degree from any state before July 2009 should be eligible for assistant professor in college or university

  30. this is totally unfair for that aspirants who cleared ugc net examination….take admission in p.hd in govt. universities is the toughest task ….so ugc net shall remain the minimum eligibility crietria for the post of assistant professor

  31. What about appointment of person having lower degree and retd from industries claim as professor???? And most of the institute appoint B.Tech student for teach to UG level.

  32. Yes net is a waste of time you can’t judge properly on some number of questions ability and capacity of a professor…….More than ability check it’s a luck check

  33. As per my view, Ph.D candidates should get exempted from clearing NET. This is because those who do research rigorously they will not get time to prepare for NET.

  34. No need equivalent PhD to net set..because many students r clear that exam so…and we no about PhD work quality so

  35. i think its a good decision of ugc.
    how just master degree holder without research experience can teach master degree programme.

  36. NET/ SLET/ SET must be compulsory for everyone to become an Assistant Professor. Even not only Ph.D. Ph.D should be compulsory for only to become an Associate Professor

  37. It’s not fare for NET qualified.NET should be must for assistant profesors.
    If this is not to be must what is the meaning of NET exam and Certificate.
    Pls don’t do anything like that.So many NET Qualified condedates are seeking for job.

  38. Please give one or two years time for clearing NET. If this is initiated suddenly then it creates unemployment in country. Already in India we are facing a Bigg unemployment problem.

  39. I think, Ph.D along with NET/SET qualification should be made mandatory for recruitment of assistant professor…NET/SET qualified candidate may have good subject knowledge but most of the times such candidates fail to explain the subject properly due to lack of teaching skills …. Moreover, if we have to create capable researchers in upcoming years, the teachers themselves should have research knowledge so that they could inspire the students towards research by sharing their research ideas. On the other hand, it has been seen that inspite of having research experience, most of the Ph.D holders are lacking thorough subject knowledge which is detrimental to the teaching profession. Hence, in my opinion,if we really wants to improve the quality of education; Ph.D. degree along with NET/SET should be made mandatory for recruitment of assistant professor…

  40. Good. NET was never a guarantee that a person will be a good teacher. Why did the UGC take so much time to understand an obvious fact? Now it should remove the obstacles in selecting a guide and a department. Research should be a field free of any practical constraints.

  41. Yes Phd is good for research but as per my think NET is mandatory for assistant professor because of Phd person is not expose with all the topics of the necessary in teaching but net qualified person is actually expose all the topics needful in teaching during preparation of NET therefor actually NET qualified person is right candidate for teaching and another reason is phd is not common plate form for All candidate but NET qualification provides common plate form for All candidate to prove them self . For pramotation Phd is mandatory but initial step first appoiment is completely on NET based is mandatory for quality of education in all the institute ferthor more the scale of post is also same as per ugc in all gov.As well as in privet institute is also mandatory.

  42. It will be a landmark decision and can bring a grate relief for the candidates waiting for a better opportunity in the field teaching. It will increase the research potentiality and encourage young students in the research field,hence increase the humen resoures in the in country.A good ph d scholar ,not only expert in teaching but also expeart in many areas of the academic field. It will reduce brain death in INDIA.

  43. Hi everyone . According to me NET/SET should be compulsory.What you call P.hd if only 1-2 % research are only genuine in India.If P.hd persons are saying they are capable why can’t they clear eligibility test.If they claim NET/SET person can’t teach postgraduate then who can teach P.hd persons.If so then why not they clear eligibility test because the question come from postgraduate syllabus of respective subject.One side discussion is over after finishing engineering student should appear for proficiency test other side to remove the test.Its injustice with the person who cleared eligibility test exams after a several attempts.Better to have similar degree for IAS/IPS and other competitive exams

  44. Its good decision as 3 hours exam can never decide knowledge of a person.
    Its very nice nice dicision taken by ugc.
    Phd is manditory for selection as ast prof

  45. Great move by UGC, inspite of thorough knowledge about the subject one can not able to have a PhD degree. It is not like an examination which have specific boundary, so every one must accept that PhD is related to research and academic interest of a candidate. In my opinion PhD candidates should be exempted from NET examination because they also cleared the entrance test conducted by the universities and spent their time to carry out their research. More ever the professors who examined the thesis are not foolish and the universities also followed the guidelines of UGC. It is my sincere request to congratulate the authorities who have taken such a historic decision.

  46. The criteria of percentage is not good. Candidates having 50% marks in graduation may loose. Today to get 80% with short questions and internal assignment is possible but not before 2000. It should be rationalized. Moreover, there should be a rotation for head of the department in colleges also so that junior teachers too can contribute and take advantage of administrative experience.

  47. Respected UGC authority.
    Kindly accept my Huge congratulations for new dreat in respect of Ph.D.
    Sir to create & sustain total quality in higher education the academic highest Ph.D degree must be made compulsory for any promotion & please keep monetary incentives gor Ph.D.

    1. good sir
      but what about those who have earned a PhD and have qualified UGC-NET/SET and in spite of having NET and PhD are not eligible for the positions just because they were a little negligent during their secondary or sr. secondary exam.
      please write to ugcregulations2017@gmail.com

  48. Doctorate is must to teach students from UG and PG departments. Because Ph. D candidate has developed sense of subject much more than set/ net qualified has not. SET / NET candidates qualify exams only by answering questions most of the times by using tricks not knowledge. Science is based on theory as well as its experimental proof. In case of Internationalisation of education system we have to upgrade education system with Intellectual teachers, who are the mostly teach subject scientifically, experimentally not theoretically. Because all of these reasons Ph. D. candidates must be Assistant professors at UG and PG levels.

  49. There are so many deemed substandard universities in India, which are issuing Ph.D. degrees with in Two years, without doing Ph.D. work. Many Ph.D. students getting registration in Tamil nadu and working in Hyderabad and in Andhrapradesh. If we really work for Ph.d it takes 5 years duration if we work per day 15 hours. From Tamilnadu many deemed universities issuing PH.D. degrees for money. SO Taking Ph.D. degree in to consideration for Assistant professor is a WRONG DICESSION. THROUGH NET/SET/SLET we can filter more knowledgeable persons.

  50. this is not good, NET should be for every post of assistant professor this is the minimum criteria please maintain the quality of education

  51. This current procedure need to be changed and revised, phd degree should be mandatory for the betterment of indian education system

  52. It is very useful decision for Ph.D degree holders who spent high amount an time to pursue the degree. We really welcome of UGC for this decision.

    Thanks You very much

  53. There are so many deemed substandard universities in India, which are issuing Ph.D. degrees with in Two years, without doing Ph.D. work. Many Ph.D. students getting registration in Tamil nadu and working in Hyderabad and in Andhrapradesh. If we really work for Ph.d it takes 5 years duration if we work per day 15 hours. From Tamilnadu many deemed universities issuing PH.D. degrees for money. SO Taking Ph.D. degree in to consideration for Assistant professor is a WRONG DICESSION. THROUGH NET/SET/SLET we can filter more knowledgeable persons.

  54. NET is a standard exam which should be mandatory as it covers the vertical knowledge from degree level to PG level and even basics of the subject which is essential for teaching. where as Ph.D covers only one particular area of research which is not sufficient for teachers. If NET is not a compulsory exam and research is compulsory then why the other apex bodies like UPSC, APPSC ETC., are conducting competitive exams to fill the positions from civils to group-d posts why cant they prefer the academic as the measuring scale. Asst. Professor is a position which needs all types of skills besides research. so, I suggest APA score and NET should be compulsory for assist. Professors.

    1. Yes, I agreed your matured decision madam. See one command, only those who is having lot of money can purchase or really pursue Ph.D. But talented poor can clear NEt but not Ph.D. NET certificate should be compulsory for appointing Assit. Professor posts in all states.

  55. Lot of PhD holders did hard work to earn the degree. So we cannot ignore them because of minor number of illegally PhD holders.

  56. Bad decesion. There should be a competitive exam for the position of a lecturer that is equal for all.
    Exempting, here will be equivalent to an uncontrolled reservation.
    For those people who think the eligibility test is easy… why can’t they attempt it then.. just as a formality so that others can know the ‘level’ of knowledge one can gain from a p.hd

  57. This is good for not only ph. D holder and also education quality. And the fellow who have completed SET,NET, exams they will be muggub and release the educational content but the ph. D holders can express the science content with their research experience and also proof. The real science is being proof something and innovative something as new. If any critical situation from other countries to our country as biowar that time we can eradicate any one problem though research only not through SET, Net, SLET, exams please maintain these regulations for safe of our country in future.

  58. This is good for not only ph. D holder and also education quality. And the fellow who have completed SET,NET, exams they will be muggub and release the educational content but the ph. D holders can express the science content with their research experience and also proof. The real science is being proof something and innovative something as new. If any critical situation from other countries to our country as biowar that time we can eradicate any one problem though research only not through SET, Net, SLET, exams please maintain these regulations for safe of our country in future. Now other countries like USA going do lot of innovative things through research but our country particularly in India discuss either research is important or unwanted. If this situation going to certain period it will damaged our country’s health. So please and should keep it up and update our research quality also through spending lot of money as it is possible.

  59. This is good for not only ph. D holder and also education quality. And the fellow who have completed SET,NET, exams they will be muggub and release the educational content but the ph. D holders can express the science content with their research experience and also proof. The real science is being proof something and innovative something as new. If any critical situation from other countries to our country as biowar that time we can eradicate any one problem though research only not through SET, Net, SLET, exams please maintain these regulations for safe of our country in future. Now other countries like USA going do lot of innovative things through research but our country particularly in India discuss either research is important or unwanted. If this situation going to certain period it will damaged our country’s health. So please and should keep it up and update our research quality also through spending lot of money.

  60. It’s a good step taken by Ugc because om another ruling ugs said that if anybody has done course work there is no need to compulsory Net. Majority of people who have completed PhD but not cracked Net. So it is a very appreciable step taken by Ugc. We welcome this step at all.

  61. I am M.Phil degree holder completed in 1994. Still I am not eligible to become lecturer. Why don’t govt consider me for the lecturer or Assistant professor post.

  62. Please take a research, the people who earned Ph.D degrees are almost children of university and educational institute staff. Simple they are purchasing Ph.D’s and getting jobs in colleges and universities by paying 30 to 40 lakhs. People who economically weaker cannot purchase Ph.D. By using their long preparation they can clear the NET or SET. But the UGC con consider, who are doing Ph.D after clearing JRF. The decision only benefis to reach people. A poor can clear IAS exam. In Tamilnadu state almost 100 percent Asst. Professor posts sold for heavy money. The UGC can fix NET eligible for pursuing Ph.D. Other wise the quality of Indian educational system will be vague. The decisions never help the poor’s. In Tamil nadu SET exams have corruption. The more weight age given for NET than SET and Ph.D. More over the research guides offering huge money for giideship.

  63. It is totally unfair..There will remain no value of clearing net after so much hard work..after clearing JRF test and doing regular phd for 5 yrs, we are left only as freshers in the market and lose teaching experience..we are totally against this notification..

    1. Doing Ph.D after clearing UGC JRF will be given priority for appointments, beacuse already cleared NET. But doing Ph.D in universities/ private universities without clearing JRF is meaningless. Plenty candidates are doing Ph.D in part time and their thesis are written by others or some other institutes is totally collapse Indian Educational system in India. The First priority given for Ph.D through JRF, then NET, SET with Ph.D., then NET with Ph.D., the SET with Ph.D should be considered. Simply doing Ph.D in universities/ private universities should not be considered. Those who purchased Assit. Professor in Jobs in colleges, please conduct the research and their quality of teaching and get feed back from the students. The aided professors have superiority complex and they involved in some other money earning activities.

  64. It is not good decision .because iss decision se un logon ko advantage hoga jinke pass paisa h we paise ke dam par Ph.D. kar lete h or jugad se job pa lenge . ye decision hamare jese poor family se belongs karane balon ke liye bahut bura sabit hoga Jo mahanat karke NET to pass kar lenge . par un ko is decision ke lagoon hone par unko 10000 month ki job bhi nahi milegi . jab inke pass buddhi h to ye NET pass kyon nahi kar lete . is decision ke bad poori shiksha vyabastha paise balon ke hathon me chali jayegi chahe un ke pass knowledge ho ya naho . yaha desh ke bhavishya ke liye subh sanket nahi h ………….

  65. This is good for not only ph. D holder and also education quality. And the fellow who have completed SET,NET, exams they will be muggub and release the educational content but the ph. D holders can express the science content with their research experience and also proof. The real science is being proof something and innovative something as new. If any critical situation from other countries to our country as biowar that time we can eradicate any one problem though research only not through SET, Net, SLET, exams please maintain these regulations for safe of our country in future.

  66. The IAS & IPS exam also muggub. The list of world’s top universities rank, Indian universities are not yet placed well. Because our system is most selfishness. If I have Ph.D, then I will support Ph.D, If I have NET, then I will support NET like that. The UGC can decide, those who are having NET, SET and Ph.D will be appoint an Assistant Professor to solve the problems after that the quality of teaching can be improved. A person who are having NET easily pursue Ph.D and a person who is having Ph.D difficult to clear NET exam. Otherwise our educational system will be inferior for ever.

  67. I see many student have passed post graduation and they work part time professor and good teaching without NET/SLET/SET of our locality.i think who have PhD holder and exempted from NET/SET/SLET.AND who are not complete PhD only that candidate need to NET/SET/SLET. i have just M COM passed .

  68. If you consider pH.d and NET are minimum qualification and why discrepancy in marks in the selection criteria. For pH.d 20 and NET 8. pH.d can be availed for money in most of the places, but not NET.

  69. NET or SET must be essential qualification with Ph.D. there should not be discrepancy in marks of both. It is very sad Ph.d.w ho study single concept getting double marks than NET qualified who study whole literature thoroughly. Hw can we get efficiency in educational system of India.

  70. Dr. Jagadeesh Netha Appalling to react by the Scholars of this country about I I have been not given marks as per the UGC Exemption. Ultimately, I am on the road and roaring. Pl. Help

  71. Good initiative, because during the process of Ph.D, candidate should go through the process of presentation, paper publication, course work and committee will Scrutinise critically and finally with publication candidate will get award. But in case of NET/SLET only they get eligibility criteia based on examination. For teaching professional it may not sufficient, so good initiation is taken by UGC. Only examination is basic criteria for eligibility but extra credential or weightage should be given for whose completed NET. If they select only on the basis of NET/SLET they time to doing research for getting promotion through CAS because Ph.D is mandatory for Associate professor. My opinion is good initiative.

  72. Respected sir..i think net is compulsory for quality education and not phd..make phd compulsory only for associate professor..and for teaching of m.sc’s students we need master in that relevent subject plus net because otherwise what is the fun of this net exam..if a student qualify net only because to fulfill the dream to became an assistant proffessor..plz don’t make people jobeless..phd is mendentory for promotion..but the minimum qualification for assistant professor is net..

  73. NET/SET should not be the main criteria. It should be Ph.D/Mph.L alone. Making an examination as the basis of teacher recruitment in higher education will affect research and innovation focus of educational systems. Nations that give importance to research are much advanced in science and technology and grew faster than that emphasis on competitive style exam for selection a professor.

  74. Why not MPhil holder net exemption 2006-2009.before the birth of new regulation 2009.I request to ugc please exemption MPhil holder2006to2009.

  75. India is a poor country but phd qualification is possible only rich people not for poor student your decision is rong &NOT JUSTIFY for net /set qualified student

  76. Net should be the minimum eligibility for working as astt professor.
    One can do ph.d from any institution (private ) and also in colleges professors take their internal students for Ph.d.
    Acc to me even in getting enrolled to Ph.d , Net must be required

  77. 2006 -2009 Ka beech Ka MPhil holder ko exemption koy nahi. Mphil ko exemption hona chahiya. Kuch university ma appointments bhee hui ha.

  78. It is not a proper justice .For a poor student it is not good.At least for assistant professor the eligibility should be net/set only.

  79. It is unfair that a candidate having PhD will get a score of 30 while the NET with Junior Research Fellowship or equivalent will earn just 7 or 5 marks.

    It will be fair if followed like based on UGC norms time to time criteria considerations.

    S.No. Academic Record Score Asst. professor post
    1 Post Graduation 10
    2 M.Phil. 10 Before 2009,UGC gave exemption .
    3 NET 10 NET is always mandatory
    4 Ph.D. 10 After 2009,UGC gave exemption for
    Ph.D based on 2009 standard
    5 TEACHING EXPERIENCE 10
    6 WRITTEN TEST 50 Exam is must because most of the
    candidate will be applied without NET

    Total score is 100

    It is well known to every one that NET is mandatory for Assistant professor post. Whenever UGC gives exemptions from NET, Corruption is going to be double.

    Before 2009 UGC gave exemption for M.Phil . Just realize that what happened at that time. It is well known to every one that all the M.Phil holders paid Rs.15 lakhs and got Asst professor post throughout India. Merit NET qualified people lost their jobs at that time.

    After 2009, UGC gave exemption for Ph.D based on 2009 standards. Again realize that what happened at that time that All the money payers paid amount 30 lakhs and got asst professor post throughout India.

    Central government should take all the states of asst professor post recruitment. It must conduct national level exam like NEET,IIT,GATE exam. Then only Corruption will come to end as well as merit and talented people will come to asst professor post. They will give standard education.

    If UGC follows and gives equal marks based on time to time considerations as well as conducts exam for recruiting asst professor post, Definitely there will be no corruption in our India and we will get high quality education.

  80. Its is a good move and the draf the should be approved,phd takes many years to complete and the research scholars get a lot of experience during that period.on the other hand NET/SET are mere competitive exams but there value not at all be nullified.but equating phd with net/set is not justified.phd should be given more credit than net/set.

  81. Net is mandatory for asst professor by ugc norms.
    PhD is exemption given by ugc.
    Ugc gives 7 or 5 marks for NET (mandatory – owner).
    But UGC gives 30 marks for PhD (exemption – tenant).
    Sense people never accept it.
    Better to stop all norms so far given.
    Fix only Net with phd is eligible.
    Say that NET ALONE or PhD Alone is not eligible.
    Otherwise give equal marks for NET/PhD.
    Never make fool among the NET/PhD. All are expert. Give equal marks for NET/PhD.
    If it goes like this, we can not stop corruption and can not develop our higher education standard. First of all stop giving exemption. To maintain standard we need to stop exemption. Otherwise it starts confusion among the qualified.

  82. Its very good decision. … i salute ………jaise ki ph.d ko priority pe rakhke seats fill kre or uske bad masters degree jo net qualified h

  83. In US, it has only 650 universities and 5000 colleges, among them 50% of students are foreigners. skilled people selected through conducting national level exam only allowed to phd registration .

    In China, it has only 600 universities and 6000 colleges, among them 30% of students are foreigners.skilled people selected through conducting national level exam only allowed to phd registration .

    In India, we have nearly 1000 universities and 50,000 colleges (now most of the colleges are conducting Shift I and Shift II due to earn lot of money, so we can consider total number of colleges as nearly 1 lakh colleges), but among them almost all the students are Indians.But here almost 50% of colleges started research centre as well as universities ,deemed universities.In India people selected without conducting national level exam for phd registration.

    It leads to money payers.It leads to corrupt higher education.It is well known to all that lakhs and lakhs of money payers phd came out from 150 deemed universities.Not only from deemed universities,it came out from most of the research centres as well as some of the universities.

    UGC killed first time Higher education when giving exemption to MPhil before 2009.

    After 2009,UGC killed second time Higher education when giving exemption to Ph.D based on 2009 standard .

    Now UGC has taken third time to kill Higher education, but before that, it has given a chance to give feedback.

    If we want to stop corruption, if we want to give standard education to our nation, we must select asst. professor post through national level exam for all the colleges in India. The recruitment exam must be conducted by central government just like NEET, GATE, IIT exam.

    Master degree ——————————-10 marks
    mphil ——————————————–10 marks
    NET———————————————–10 marks
    PhD ———————————————-10 marks
    Teaching experience ———————-10 marks
    Written exam by Central govt ———50 marks

    total ——————————————-100 marks

  84. Last year UGC said that 150 deemed university are not recognized. Now that 150 deemed university changed their name into technology.Still it is running.What about lakhs and lakhs of PhD came out from that universities for the last 10 years.It is true that most of the research centre are selling PhD.It is true that some of the universities are doing like this.We do not know where it is going on.Just like nursery school, research centre will be started each and every street in future.We must stop it. PhD registration must be selected through national level exam conducted by central govt. Phd must do only in universities.India has 1000 Universities.When compared to other countries, we have lot of universities.We must fix NET exam for PhD completed without JRF/NET.

  85. UGC accepted that So far 40,000 fake journals has found in India. More than crores fake papers were published through fake journals by getting money for the last 10 years. It is not education, it is just like business. Fakers make a lot of fakers.Fake journals are getting money 5000 to 7000 and easily published papers. So far even a single paper could not be recognized in world level. Everything is cut copy paste method. Recently UGC has said that there are 9000 approved journal list. The entire research centre has got ISBN number and started journal and publishing journal papers yearly twice. Each centre is publishing minimum 50,000 papers yearly by getting lot of money without review. But they said that we have done properly .Every thing is cut copy paste.Actually we would have got lots of lot nobel prizes for our so far published papers in this time, but we could not get recognized for even a single nobel prize.After declared this draft,during this month only ,most of them started to pay 21,000 for publishing 3 papers to get 6 marks (7000 for each paper) to the journals.They are ready to publish these papers.It is time to them to earn money. Better our Govt must conduct exam for recruiting asst professor post like SSC, NEET,IAS.That will not lead to corruption.That will bring standard higher education.

  86. NET/SET should not be the main criteria. It should be Ph.D alone. Making an examination as the basis of teacher recruitment in higher education will affect research and innovation focus of educational systems. Nations that give importance to research are much advanced in science and technology and grew faster than that emphasis on competitive style exam for selection a professor. As new youngster will enter for research if Ph.D. is the eligibility criteria for selection of Assistant Professor rather than Net/Set . And also Ph.D. is full matured for teaching.

  87. It is unfair that a candidate having PhD will get a score of 30 while the NET with Junior Research Fellowship or equivalent will earn just 7 or 5 marks.
    UGC is conducting NET exam for the last more than 15 years. It says that NET is mandatory for Asst. professor post for the last more than 15 years.
    More than 5 lakhs people cleared NET exam so far. More than 10 lakhs people cleared SET exam also so far. It is nearly 15 lakhs people cleared NET/SET exam.
    Without NET/JRF more than lakhs and lakhs people have got PhD so far. Now UGC says that it is going to give exemption for Phd and gives 30 marks for PhD. But it also says that it is going to give 7 or 5 marks for NET mandatory. It is really ashamed when it asks for public feedback. Really educated people never do like that, they said that NET is mandatory and also conducting exam still now. It indicates that educated Indians are fools. Sense people never accept it.
    If we want to change pattern, it must give equal marks and must give equal chance for all qualified.
    After 2022, UGC may follow
    Assistant Professor ————- NET with PhD only
    Associate Professor————- PhD with API score (promotion)
    Professor————————— PhD with more API score (promotion)
    Until 2022 , UGC must follow
    Assistant Professor—————- NET / PhD ( must give equal marks )
    Associated Professor————- PhD with API score (promotion)
    Professor—————————– PhD with more API score (promotion)
    Now It may stop NET, SET exam for Asst professor. Now onwards It must conduct NET exam only for PhD registration. NET qualified only can start PhD without stipend. JRF qualified can start PhD with stipend.
    So far NET/SET qualified must complete PhD before 2022, otherwise their NET/SET will not be valid after 2022.
    Similarly so far PhD completed people must complete NET before 2022, otherwise their PhD will not be valid after 2022.
    Because after 2022, Asst professor norm must be NET with PhD, if UGC says like that. If it follows like that, every one think that UGC is going to be equal for all qualified.
    Until 2022, UGC must follow for assistant professor post recruitment like as follows
    Master degree ——————————-10 marks
    mphil ——————————————–10 marks
    NET———————————————–10 marks
    PhD ———————————————-10 marks
    Teaching experience ———————-10 marks
    Written exam by Central govt ———50 marks

    total ——————————————-100 marks

  88. NET/SET should be the basic qualification. Ph.D may be additional qualification which will be considered for giving promotion. Don’t exempt Ph.D holders from qualifying NET.

  89. PhD and net should not be compared as getting PhD degree is not a joke. If phd holders are exempted then research could be boosted. If only net remained the only eligibility then please think about the scope of research in future because net cleared would never opt for such a long time to be invested in further studies because after post graduation they are already delivering lectures so what else they would be aspiring more. Getting phd is not that easy and the selectors are experienced enough to distinguish between a bought and an earned phd. How a professor without any research experience could encourage a student to enter into the research field. Research could loose its potential in future which is not a good thing.

  90. NET / SET used to evaluate subject specific not domain / research specific. if I am good academic student I can clear NET/SET with good marks, but not PhD or PDF.

    Last year PG student teaching to current year PG student with NET qualification will not carry any value.

    Initially NET accepted and encourage by government due to CAGR of Student enrollment and faculty ratio in India, whereas current situation show we have enough PhD resource in India and they are migrating to foreign countries due to less reorganization which impact India in longer run. eg: refer china research publication and H index every year we are similar in terms of demographic but China is well worse than India in education and literacy.

    No one can learn driving from books or theories until they have practice it what they learn.

    NET/SET with Minimum 4 years Industry experience
    PhD with min 1 years Industry experience

    could be preferred profile for Teaching.

  91. I think this is a good decision for a pH d holder to exempt net.net and pH d holders are against together.I think ugc should start exam for asst prfsr Nd says net and PhD holders are eligible for it.then every thing will be good

  92. Ph.D holders must be exempted from NET /SLET for the recruitment of Assistant Professor in both colleges and universities because it take 4 to 5 years intensive research to get it and acquire vast knowledge about research and teaching as well. Quality teacher produce quality student.

  93. Employment opportunity of both net and PhD persons protected. After long period of education each person qualify Net/PhD. So it’s each value must be admitted.

Got Something To Say:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*
*